Justin Bieber and wife Hailey Bieber appear to have reopened a Pandora’s box of social media debate about their relationship with a seemingly simple move.
The skincare mogul, 29, took to Instagram on New Year’s Eve and shared a throwback photo with her beau, 31, celebrating 10 years of welcoming in the new year together.
Social media leaders noted that Daisies the hitmaker and the Rhode founder have been dating since 2018, reconnecting after their brief relationship in 2015, and getting married just months later.
While it’s unclear which specific New Year’s Eves Hailey and Justin celebrated together, netizens quickly began speculating about some overlap between the periods Baby The singer dated his famous ex-girlfriend, Selena Gomez, and the supermodel.
It’s been known that Justin’s two relationships had non-linear timelines since he also reconnected with Selena after their first split, but Hailey’s new post brought the drama back to the surface.
X-users began re-sharing old videos from the time, with the couple claiming they weren’t necessarily “exclusive” and raising questions about their relationship again.
The mother of one and the Grammy winner faced many rumors last summer – including rumors of separation and divorce, which they were only able to escape after numerous interviews and the release of Justin’s two albums, Swag and Swag IIwhich provide vulnerable insights into their relationship.
Neither Justin nor Hailey have addressed the rekindled drama yet.



